Ben Hogan, among others, considered Bill Mehlhorn (1898-1988) one of the finest ball-strikers they had ever seen. Mehlhorn’s most prestigious victory was in the 1924 Western Open at the Calumet Country Club (Chicago area). At that time, the Western Open was one of the most important championships in the country. In the U.S. Open play between 1922 and 1931 he finished third three times, fourth twice, and in the top 15 on three other occasions. Ultimately, it was his putting that held him back.
A first-rank swing theorist, as his eventful life drew to a close, Mehlhorn moved his family to Miami, Florida; where he was teaching golfers at the Fontainebleau Golf Course. That course served as a practice or home venue for the Florida International University (FIU) golf team. It was there that I first met Mr. Mehlhorn. He was a close associate of our Golf Coach Bob Shave. Mehlhorn and Shave wrote the book, Golf Secrets Exposed, in the early 1980s to summarize Mehlhorn’s golf secrets and insight.
William Earl Mehlhorn was born in Elgin, Illinois, on December 2, 1898. His German-born father was a brick-layer and moved the family to Glencoe, a suburb of Chicago, to provide them a better life.
In the spring of 1909, ten-year-old Bill got into golf because some of his school chums talked about caddying. At Skokie Country Club, he found within the club’s pristine grounds a new world of almost-addictive fun. For his first eighteen holes as a bag-toter, the youngster was paid thirty cents. He said, “Three dimes. It was like a million dollars.”
From day one the game of golf intrigued him and he developed in it very fast. Mehlhorn said, “I had a knack for it.” He continued, “But my [approach to] golf might be different than anybody else’s, because baseball was my first love. And everything I teach in golf is the same as hitting a baseball.” Throwing underhanded across the body, or sidearmed, is the way you should swing a golf club.
Melhorn believed that there is only one thing that helps everybody play golf, and it can be used in every solitary thing that takes movement. He famously said, “Muscles and joints at ease in their movements, that’s the secret to the golf game. There should not be any intention of hardening any muscle or joint. And the elbow joint is the most important [one] we have.” He continued, “And every doctor will tell you that the harder you make your muscles, the less you can move. So why should there be any intentional hardening of the muscles, which is promoted by the word “firm”? I contradict the use of that word in golf, completely.
The experienced, wise figure added, “Another thing I contradict in golf theories is one-piece action. There’s too many pieces moving. A smart person will say that the pieces move independently but in unison. Another thing I’m against is full extension. Full extension is stretching. You’re retarding something when you stretch it.”
Golf swing instructions have been explained in numerous ways since the ancient game reached our shores from Scotland in the 1880s. Top instructors and PGA Tour players often emphasize different, sometimes contradictory, feel-based or technical methods to achieve consistent ball striking.
I found the following section of an interview that my father had with Senior Editor Bill Fields of Golf Illustrated Magazine in February 1988 to be both interesting and thought-provoking. Take a look:
THE TOP TEACHERS TALK
Q & A
Golf Illustrated: There seems to be a lot of reference in current golf instruction to baseball. Bill Mehlhorn talked about it always, and still does.
Jack Grout: Bill had a lot of technique. But I couldn’t learn anything from him because he didn’t hold on to the club any more than a little child would. The club was flying around in his hands.
Golf Illustrated: You don’t believe in a light, feathery grip?
Jack Grout: You don’t want to grip the club like it was your last dollar. But you don’t let it flop around.
The “Wild Bill” of the PGA Tour
Two distinctive things about Bill Mehlhorn: His hats and his putting/chipping yips. The “Wild Bill” nickname was after Wild Bill Hickok, the cowboy who was murdered while playing cards. Mehlhorn was an enthusiastic tabletop games player and often played (cards, checkers and golf) in hats. Sometimes, especially early in his career, that was a cowboy hat. Sometimes it was a safari hat or a fedora. Often there was a cigarette dangling from his lips.
In An Oral History of American Golf by Al Barkow, Mehlhorn is quoted as saying, “My nickname, “Wild Bill,” has nothing to do with me having any kind of temper, as a lot of people have thought. I’ll tell you, Leo Diegel gave me the name “Oklahoma Bill” when I went to Tulsa in 1920. It stands to reason. Then we had a cyclone and he changed it to “Cyclone Bill.” I tried to stop that wild stuff, because I thought it hurt my image, but that’s what made it stick, trying to fight it. The nickname had nothing to do with temperament, but with my shooting some impossible scores.”
As for his golf game: Mehlhorn was acknowledged in his time as a great golfer tee-to-green. His problem was in the short game, particularly putting. He had the yips, even if the term “the yips” wasn’t yet common. Mehlhorn got so nervous over some putts that those watching could see his hands twitch.
In 1934, Bobby Jones wrote about his own issues with occasional nerviness while putting, but held up Mehlhorn as the best (or is that worst?) example. Jones wrote about watching Mehlhorn attempt a 3-foot putt, only to twitch so badly in the attempt that he knocked the ball across the green and into a bunker.
Paul Runyan, in his 1963 Book for Senior Golfers, connected Mehlhorn’s yips to his nickname by writing that “Wild Bill” “was a nickname that fitted only his short game.”
Paul Runyan, who had one of the all-time great short games, told this story about Mehlhorn:
“Bill was a hardy soul, somehow able to stand the ruin of these sudden wristy putting and chipping lapses spread through otherwise superlative rounds. But at any time his wrists might snap uncontrollably and would send the ball almost anywhere. These twitches happened sometimes right next to the hole. I once saw him carry an 8-foot putt past the cup on the fly, to run 15 feet or so off the green.”
Jack Grout, who played on the PGA Tour from 1931 through 1949, told this story about Mehlhorn:
“Bill set tongues wagging during the third round of the 1936 Santa Catalina Open. Twice “Wild Bill” hit the ball while it was moving, this rules violation costing him two strokes each time. On top of that, during a weather delay at the tournament, ‘all hell broke loose’ as Jimmy Demaret and Mehlhorn squared off in a game of checkers. ‘It was a bad, rainy day,’ Dad said, “and this Mehlhorn was a whale of a checkers player. But ol’ Jimmy beat him bad. I remember one game where Mehlhorn sat back and just said, ‘It can’t be done,’ but Jimmy had him all right.” It was a good thing, too, because Demaret won enough money from Mehlhorn to pay the hotel bill for himself and me.”
Mehlhorn’s tee-to-green game had to be exceptional with such short game issues, and when he had a decent week with the putter Mehlhorn was around the lead. Today Bill Mehlhorn is credited with 19 official PGA Tour wins, the same number as Ben Crenshaw, Ernie Els, Doug Ford, Hubert Green and Tom Kite — all Hall of Famers. At the time of his 19th win in 1930, Mehlhorn’s career total would have ranked in the All-Time Top 10.
Bill Mehlhorn’s PGA Tour Victories:
1923 Oklahoma Open
1924 Western Open
1926 Long Beach Open
1926 South Central Open
1926 South Florida Open Championship
1926 Santa Clara Valley Open
1926 San Jose Open
1927 San Jose Open
1928 Long Beach Open (tie with Leo Diegel)
1928 Texas Open
1928 Richmond Open
1928 Montauk Open
1928 Westchester Open
1928 Hawaiian Open
1929 El Paso Open
1929 Texas Open
1929 South Central Open
1929 Metropolitan Open
1930 La Gorce Open

WORCESTER COUNTRY CLUB – WORCESTER, MASSACHUSETTS
1927
(L-R) Al Watrous, Bill Mehlhorn, Leo Diegel, Johnny Golden, Walter Hagen (Captain), Al Espinosa, Gene Sarazen, Johnny Farrell and Joe Turnesa
William “Wild Bill” Mehlhorn was 90 years old when he died on April 5, 1989 in Miami, Florida. He is a member of the Metropolitan PGA Hall of Fame and the Elgin (Illinois) Sports Hall of Fame.




















